Instead, I got those plastic eggs, and DH and I came up with 12 things about each child that we love about them--some funny things, some serious--printed them out, and put them inside the eggs. It was a fun surprise! I used a sharpie and put the initial of who it was for on the egg so each child had to find their own eggs.
I'm telling you, it was so awesome! I'm trying not to pat my own back too hard here, but I'm so happy when one of my schemes, er I mean ideas, turns out well for a change!! :)